top of page
Search

Congressional Retrieval of Powers after Trump v. Slaughter

1 day ago
3 min read

An Analysis of how The Supreme Court Is Making It Harder for Congress to Reclaim Its Power

Published 11/15/26

Written by Colin Burns


Earlier this year, the Supreme Court ruled in Trump v. Slaughter that the president has the authority to fire the heads of independent agencies. The case involved the Federal Trade Commission, an independent agency tasked with protecting consumers and promoting fair competition. Rebecca Slaughter, a member of the FTC board, was fired by President Trump without specifying a cause for removal, a violation of federal law at the time.


Independent agencies, such as the Federal Trade Commission or the Securities and Exchange Commission, are similar to other federal agencies but have a distinct structure. The heads of independent agencies were given for-cause removal protections, meaning the president must prove “inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office” to fire any of the heads. Thus, the court striking down these removal protections made President Trump’s firing of Ms. Slaughter lawful.


The Supreme Court's decision in Slaughter was based on the finding that independent agencies hold executive power. In his majority opinion, Chief Justice John Roberts explained that “The FTC not only investigates businesses to ensure they comply with its statutes and rules, but enforces those statutes and rules through in-house adjudications.” They also “file civil suits on behalf of the United States in federal court.” All of these powers are executive in nature.


The court reasoned that restricting the president's power over the agencies violated Article 2 of the U.S. Constitution, which vests all executive power in the president.Though this is a very reasonable rationale, the majority’s lack of constitutional foresight could be a major misstep as the decision continues the accumulation of power within the executive.


Independent agencies like the FTC also possess major legislative power along with their executive authority. As Roberts explained, “The FTC has the power to promulgate substantive rules that carry the force of law.” With the Slaughter decision, the President will have complete control over these congressional powers without any checks. 


Congress delegated broad legislative powers to these agencies with the expectation that they would remain insulated from executive control through the removal protections. When the court struck down those protections in Slaughter, they left the rest of the congressional delegation in place, causing major issues related to separation of powers. 


This isn’t the first time the Supreme Court has made this costly error. Beginning in the 1930’s, Congress was continuing to abdicate its powers and responsibilities to the executive branch through administrative agencies. To do so, they often added a legislative veto to these broad delegations of power. This allowed Congress to veto any rules or actions taken by the executive branch with their newfound power. Congress’s veto power didn’t last long as the Supreme Court struck down the legislative veto in INS v. Chadha (1983). Similar to Slaughter, instead of ruling the entire delegation as unconstitutional, the court only removed the legislative veto.This left the executive branch with expansive legislative powers without the one check Congress put in place. 


These court rulings have major implications for the separation of powers. For starters, it is difficult to know if these delegations would have gotten the support of congress if they knew the checks placed on the executive wouldn’t last. Lawmakers look at proposed legislation holistically, and many were likely supportive of giving away some lawmaking authority solely because there would still be checks on that power. Even if Congress wanted to reclaim their power, that process is incredibly challenging, way more so than it was to delegate the powers in the first place. 


Congress gave these powers away through a simple majority vote in both houses and the president's approval. If Congress wanted to regain its power through legislation, it would almost assuredly be vetoed by the president, requiring a ⅔ majority in each house to override that veto. To illustrate how rare this is, out of the almost 2,600 presidential vetoes in US history, only 112 have been overridden by congress, a 4.3% overturn rate. This retrieval problem makes it incredibly difficult for Congress to take back their powers, even if a majority of lawmakers believe it is necessary.


Due to the difficulty of Congress to retrieve the legislative power that is rightfully theirs, it is the Supreme Court’s responsibility to enforce the separation of powers. Many of these delegations were unconstitutional the moment they were signed, even with the former checks put in place. The Supreme Court took a step in the right direction in Slaughter returning executive power back to the president, but the job isn’t finished. The Court has the tools and the resources to revive a dormant legislative branch, and now is the time to act.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page