top of page
Search

Boulder v. Big Oil

1 day ago
6 min read

Who Pays for Climate Change? Boulder Takes Big Oil to the Supreme Court

Published 11/15/26

Written by Tristan Carrington


The Path to the Bench


On October 5th, 2026, the US Supreme Court heard oral arguments for Suncor Energy Inc. and Exxon Mobil Corporation v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, according to the Denver Gazette. The County of Boulder originally brought the case in hopes of pursuing civil restitution for the oil companies' alleged role in global climate change. In 2018, Boulder County and San Miguel County filed the lawsuit alleging that Exxon and Suncor contributed to climate change by misleading the public about the risks associated with oil and gas. Today, the case only involves Boulder County, as San Miguel County’s claims now proceed as a separate case in Denver District Court. Boulder County, however, continues to seek monetary compensation for the costs of climate-related infrastructure and public health expenses, says Ballotpedia News.


Boulder’s legal claims stem from ordinary Colorado tort law, the same law people use to sue over everyday civil wrongs that cause losses or harm to a person, property, or reputation. They claim that the companies have not been forthcoming about the climate risks of burning their products, and less fuel would have been used had they told the buyers. Importantly, Boulder is looking for monetary reimbursement rather than a Court ruling to stop company sales. 


Questions Asked of the Court


SCOTUSblog reports that both Suncor and Exxon have repeatedly asked courts to dismiss the case. Because Boulder sued under Colorado law, the companies argued that federal law and the federal government’s authority in foreign policy take precedence over state law, which would leave Boulder without a legal basis for its claims. On May 12, however, a ruling by the Colorado Supreme Court rejected their defense, holding that neither federal common law nor the Clean Air Act preempts Boulder’s claims. At that point, Suncor and Exxon appealed to the Supreme Court. Notably, before the Supreme Court can rule on the viability of Boulder’s claims, it must first decide whether Boulder has the legal merit to bring the lawsuit at all based on the preemption of federal law over state law. Even the Colorado Supreme Court expressed no opinion concerning the validity of Boulder’s claims, meaning that the lawsuit could continue forward. However, a Supreme Court win for Boulder would only send the case back to Colorado, where Boulder would still have to prove its claims.


Before assessing the merits of the case, the Supreme Court must also weigh whether it has jurisdiction over it in the first place. The Supreme Court can only review a state-court case after the state’s highest court has issued a final judgment. Given that Boulder’s case is still pending in Colorado trial court, the Supreme Court must determine whether it agrees with Suncor’s view that the Colorado Supreme Court’s ruling counts as a final judgment. Alternatively, the Court may find that the ruling was only an ordinary appeal that it lacks jurisdiction to review. 


There is also the issue of whom Boulder can hold liable for climate change. Specifically, can two companies be solely responsible for climate change? Does it fall on the consumer who does the actual burning of the fuel, contributing to the release of carbon dioxide, or on the company that produced the fuel? And is it possible for Colorado’s state law to have legal jurisdiction over conduct occurring everywhere across the world?


The Case for Each Side


The companies’ best argument will lie in their claims that it’s difficult to pinpoint interstate pollution as an intrastate matter, especially since courts have historically treated it as a federal matter and it is currently a problem with global effects. Justice Kavanaugh argued that no new interpretations were necessary to decide the case. Cases such as Milwaukee I, Milwaukee II, Ouellette and AEP, Just Security reports, already established that federal law governs this kind of pollution unless Congress says otherwise. Additionally, Chief Justice Roberts argued that should a successful ruling for Boulder occur, a massive spike in suits against such fossil fuel companies would ensue, causing mass liability across the nation, potentially bankrupting the corporations.


Contrary to Suncor and Exxon’s constitutional argument, Boulder’s litigation responded that the case is not actually about the regulation of emissions at all. Their claim was simply that it may apply its own state laws to injuries that out-of-state emissions caused. While federal statutes concerning emissions do displace federal common law, they do not similarly preempt state common law. The distinction between the two questions matters. The constitutional question asks whether Colorado can apply its laws to this kind of harm at all, and the liability question asks whether the companies actually broke those laws. Under this framing, the case ceases to be about constitutionality and considers whether the companies were being deceitful or neglecting to divulge information that could have prevented climate costs Boulder has incurred.


Boulder has the Better Shot


The companies want the Court to believe Boulder wants to set a precedent that will control emissions regulation across the US and the world. In fact, the companies’ defense attorney, Kannon Shanmugam, claims that “if Boulder’s claims are allowed to go forward, some 90,000 municipalities across the country will have the ability to make national and international energy policy by asking juries to impose catastrophic damages on selected fossil-fuel producers.” This, however, misinterprets the core ideas of Boulder’s arguments. Boulder claims that the companies’ misrepresentations contributed to the unchecked growth in fossil fuel use, which in turn led to the climate harms Boulder has suffered over the past decade. Despite both Shanmugam's and Justice Roberts' concerns about a large influx of cases concerning climate injustices, that reason alone should not dictate the Court’s ruling. If this does become a problem, it should be up to Congress to create policy rather than rely on the Courts to deal with it legally. Either way, the lawsuit concerns the ethics of misleading the public, not emissions regulations.


Interestingly, the companies’ position leads to a paradoxical result. Where federal common law once gave complainants a way to sue over cross-border pollution, the passing of the Clean Air Act displaced this mechanism. If the Court rules that the Clean Air Act also displaced state common law, then no court could hear Boulder’s claims. A law Congress intended to control air pollution nationwide would leave affected communities with no way to seek compensation in any court of law. The intention to reduce pollution could result in giving companies immunity rather than holding them accountable.


Many Possibilities


Justice Samuel Alito’s recusal following pressure from environmental groups concerned about a conflict of interest due to his stock ownership in oil companies lies at the center of the case’s possible outcomes. His recusal opens up the case to the possibility of a 4-4 split, meaning that the Colorado Supreme Court ruling would remain in place for Boulder, but the Court would set no binding precedent. The Court may also decide that it should not have taken on the case in the first place due to jurisdiction or federalism issues. In the event of a dismissal of certiorari, the Colorado Supreme Court ruling would also remain in place.


If, however, the Court finds that the case is worth ruling on and finds it in Boulder’s favor, it would have national consequences. Avenues that previously existed would remain open, allowing communities to bring state tort suits against international fossil-fuel producers in cases concerning interstate conflict. Conversely, a ruling in favor of Suncor and Exxon would severely limit climate litigation, taking away an important legal tool that communities have used to pursue claims that hold fossil-fuel producers accountable.


Who Bears the Cost?


When Boulder initially filed its lawsuit in 2018, its residents had already lived through the Fourmile Canyon fire in 2010 and the floods of 2013, which displaced thousands and caused more than $4 billion in damages, according to The Denver Gazette. Disasters like these are the kinds of costs Boulder wants the companies to help pay for. Whether climate change is responsible for these events, or whether Suncor and Exxon can be causally linked to them, is what Boulder will have to prove. The companies, however, are asking the Supreme Court if Boulder should even be allowed to try to prove its claims.


Because the Court is deciding only whether Boulder can make its case, not whether it wins, Boulder has the stronger argument. The companies want to close the case before a court can even hear the evidence, leaving Boulder to deal with the repercussions of a community it believes the companies misled. Boulder may well lose at trial, but when dealing with the Supreme Court, I believe the companies’ concerns are a matter of policy rather than law. As such, Boulder’s claims should be allowed to reach trial.


Beyond the outcome of the case, Suncor Energy Inc. and Exxon Mobil Corporation v. County Commissioners of Boulder County is not about whether these companies should be allowed to produce and sell fossil fuels; it's about who bears the costs of the harm they cause, and what body of government should respond. With a decision that affects dozens of lawsuits beyond the aforementioned hanging in the balance, a decision either way could shape the future of environmental law for decades to come.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page